Just like building a house, editing isn’t a single step: you need a solid foundation, a sturdy frame, stable walls, and the finishing touches. It’s an intensive process, and each editing stage serves an essential purpose. This guide breaks down the four primary editing stages—beta reading, structural editing, content editing, and proofreading—so you can understand how they work, when each one is needed, and how to choose the right path for your document or manuscript.

​​Some of the links in this post might be affiliate links. This means that if you click on the link and make a purchase, we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products or services that we personally use and believe will add value to our readers.

An Editor’s Process: Polishing With Intention

Good editing is complex and time-consuming. An editor often finishes an edit by reading the draft several times, spending many hours poring over and organizing the details. Each document is wildly different. The varied needs of distinct genres, age ranges, and goals require the editor to have a broad knowledge base—and the ability to fact-check accurately when needed.

Before an edit, an editor will have trained either in college, through certification programs, or on their own to learn the ups and downs of grammar, punctuation, spelling, flow, clarity, engagement, pacing, world-building, character progression, and countless other fundamental pillars of storytelling.

During the edit, an editor must keep an enormous amount of information hovering in their brain, storing it for when it’s needed next. They have to organize, tidy, and polish the words while always maintaining the author’s voice, tone, and intention.

After the primary edit, the revision process begins, during which the author and the editor work together to ensure the manuscript or document is exactly as the author wants it. All that information on standby in the editor’s brain must remain at the ready. It’s a rigorous process, but necessary and rewarding.

And this is all after the magic of an author giving it their all to write the first draft.

Because the approach is unique to the editor, the author, and the draft, the editing process must be tailored accordingly. That’s where editing stages come into play.

Choosing the Right Editing Stages: Save Time, Money, and Frustration

There is no shame in completing as many of the editing stages as you can yourself. But sending a document or manuscript for proofreading when it really needs a good structural edit can be tricky for both the author and the editor. The editor will try their best to polish a disheveled document, while the author will likely be unimpressed with the still-not-publishable results. This common situation is why it’s so important to know what tier of editing your work needs and progress from there.

The Process: Four Primary Editing Stages

At Pursuit Press, we have four main editing stages:

Beta reading is the first of the editing stages, which involves a thorough read and evaluation of the document. No actual editing takes place, but because a good beta read determines the type of editing needed next, we consider this the most fundamental step of the editing process—like laying the foundation of a house.

Structural editing is the second of the editing stages, which involves fixing the “structure” of the document, including plot, pacing, chapter order, POV, theme, world-building, and genre alignment. We like to think of this as paragraph- and chapter-level editing, or like working on the frame of a house.

Content editing is the third of the editing stages, which involves tightening clarity, voice, tone, and dialogue while reducing repetition and wordiness. We think of this as sentence-level editing, or like working on the walls and fixtures of a house.

Proofreading is the fourth of the editing stages, which involves polishing the grammar, punctuation, spelling, and formatting of the document. We think of this as word- or character-level editing, or like working on the paint and decorations of a house.

Following these steps is critical, whether you do it yourself or with an editor, as each builds on the previous steps. A very disorganized document that hasn’t been structurally edited will get little benefit from a proofread. The grammar might be better, but it will remain sloppy and structurally unsound.

A basic understanding of the editing stages benefits every writer, whether you’re revising on your own or partnering with a professional editor to guide the process. So, to make this simple, we’ll walk through each tier in order—starting with beta reading.

Beta Read: Big-Picture Foundational Feedback

What a Beta Read Is—and Is Not

Think of beta reading as laying the foundation for a new house. Without a solid foundation, the house won’t last very long. A professional beta read typically includes a thorough read-through that focuses on the story’s fundamental building blocks and will likely include inline comments and a detailed reader report.

At Pursuit Press, we also include a detailed Book Blueprint that allows our beta readers to track key details, such as characters, locations, and style quirks. Beta readers usually avoid any editing, though it is sometimes difficult to help ourselves. Glaring typos or mistakes can be distracting, but that is also something we will make note of in the Reader Report and Book Blueprint.

If you are reaching out to friends, family, or informal beta reading groups, they likely won’t provide in-line comments or a Reader Report. However, being much cheaper or even free, it is still very worth it to have another set of eyes on your draft.

Key Areas Addressed in a Beta Read

Beta readers focus on the foundational, bigger-picture elements of the manuscript, including:

• pacing (Does the story move too quickly? Too sluggishly?).
• engagement (Are the characters likable? Relatable? Morally complex enough? Am I interested in what is happening, or does the outcome not matter to me?).
• clarity (Are the characters and locations consistent? Does the timeline fit seamlessly? Is the word choice appropriate for the target demographics?).
• emotional impact (Does it tug at my heartstrings? Will I remember this book after I read it? Or does it fall flat, leaving me feeling ambivalent?).

Signs You Need a Beta Read

Your manuscript is ready for a beta read when it is finished or very nearly finished. Often, authors can find trusted friends or family who are willing to do the first beta reads. This can be incredibly helpful. If you know someone with an eye for storytelling, go for it. It’s always beneficial to save money during the editing process.

ARC (Advanced Reader’s Copy) groups are also excellent resources for new authors. Groups can be found on:

• Facebook.
• Reddit.
• Goodreads.
• Scribophile.
• Critique Circle.
• Storyfolk.

Try those sites to find genre- and age-specific groups that will surely welcome you with open arms. There are many people out there who are ready for their next favorite read from an up-and-coming author.

A professional comes in if friends, family, or ARC groups just don’t fit your process, or if you’ve exhausted those avenues and are still seeking additional feedback before embarking on the rigorous editing journey. The right professional will know their stuff and have a solid process.

At Pursuit Press, we view beta reading as the first step in the editing process and follow many of the same steps we use in the other editing stages. Because of this, our deliverables are consistent and deeply helpful.

Note: Here at Pursuit Press, we call it beta reading, but you might also see it referred to as a reader review, narrative assessment, or manuscript critique.

Structural Edit: Fixing the Framework

What a Structural Edit Is—and Is Not

Think of structural editing as working on the frame of a new house. The frame has to be solid and strong for the construction to continue. You can theoretically continue building if the frame is flimsy and unsound, but you risk a disastrous crumble in the future.

Writing is the same. If your initial structure is haphazard and lacks a unified theme and an understandable plot, it will be terribly difficult to continue both the writing and editing process. Focusing on grammar and punctuation won’t help much if your story is overly convoluted or filled with plot holes. So if your beta reader indicates that some foundational work is due, listen to them and get going on a structural edit.

Key Areas Addressed in a Structural Edit

A structural edit focuses on the building blocks that shape a manuscript and keep everything held together, including:

• overall plot and pacing.
• narrative structure.
• character arcs and development.
• point of view.
• scene purpose and order.
• tension and stakes.
• thematic coherence.
• start-to-finish clarity.

If you put up the plaster and lath before your home’s frame is secure, it won’t serve you as you would like. It will likely all come crashing down at the most inopportune time.

Likewise, the structural strength of your story determines if it is ultimately readable. If it is nonsensical or disorganized, the beauty of the prose or the polished grammar won’t matter. Your manuscript, essay, or cover letter will be discarded before the first page—or sentence—is finished. Slushpiles are rarely forgiving.

Signs You Need a Structural Edit

Do your family and friends have a distinct look of confusion when reading your manuscript? Does your beta reader ask you questions like, “Wait, why is this chapter here? Shouldn’t this go at the end of the book?” Or when reading your own manuscript, do you find yourself second-guessing the plot, character development, thematic consistency, or overall clarity? Those are good signs that a structural edit is due.

Note: Here at Pursuit Press, we call it structural editing, but you might also see it referred to as developmental editing, substantive editing, or an editorial assessment.

Content Edit: Strengthening the Writing Itself

What a Content Edit Is—and Is Not

Think of a content edit as working on the plaster and lath, sheetrock, insulation, and siding—buttoning up an already strong foundation and frame. You aren’t focusing on the finishing touches quite yet, but you are ensuring your home is sound for that final polish.

Key Areas Addressed in a Content Edit

As such, in writing, a content edit will focus on:

• clarity and precision.
• voice and tone consistency.
• dialogue and paragraph flow.
• repetition and wordiness.

A content edit is not focused on big-picture structural issues, and an editor typically isn’t moving around chapters or modifying characters’ arcs. The edit also isn’t zeroed in on nitpicky grammar and punctuation. It is comfortably nestled somewhere in between.

Signs You Need a Content Edit

Have you, your family, friends, or a professional editor worked hard to organize and tighten the narrative structure, plot and pacing, character development, POV, tension, and thematic coherence, but still need a little help with dialogue, flow, wordiness, clarity, or repetition?

If so, then you are ready for a comprehensive content edit. If not, consider heading back to a beta read or structural edit. Conversely, if you think it is beyond the content edit stage and ready for some polishing, that’s where the final step—proofreading—comes in.

Note: Here at Pursuit Press, we call it content editing, but you might also see it referred to as copy editing, line editing, or mechanical editing. For simplicity’s sake, we combined two commonly distinct yet similar stages of editing, line and copy editing, into one encompassing category: content editing.

Proofreading: The Final Polish

What Proofreading Is—and Is Not

Think of proofreading as the final touches in a home, such as painting, furniture, and decorations. These are the final flourishes in an already foundationally and structurally sound home, all buttoned up. Without those previous steps, there would be no house to decorate—or you’d be decorating a house that was soon to fall.

Likewise, in writing, proofreading is the final touch that ensures the draft is reader-ready. No reorganization or significant plot changes here—those should have already been addressed and fixed.

Key Areas Addressed in a Proofread

Proofreading primarily fixes:

• grammar.
• spelling.
• punctuation.
• formatting consistency.

Signs You Are Ready for a Proofread 

If you have worked your tail off to strengthen your manuscript from the ground up, and you are confident that all the foundational, structural, and content issues have been addressed, you may be ready for a proofread.

Additionally, if you or a layout artist has formatted your manuscript in InDesign or Vellum and it is the absolute final draft before publication or sharing (AKA: a proof), now is the time to proofread. After all your hard work, make sure your final draft is as grammatically and mechanically correct as it can be. Your document deserves it.

But don’t forget: if you must go back and tweak a few structural or content issues after proofreading is complete, have those sections proofread again. This sometimes happens during the revision process and is expected for small sections.

Note: Here at Pursuit Press, we call it proofreading, but you might also see it referred to as a final polish, proofing pass, or quality check.

When Choosing Between Editing Stages: Questions To Ask

If you answer yes to these questions, consider the following editing stages.

Will people like my book?
Beta Read

Is my story or argument working as a whole?
Beta Read or Structural Edit

Is my plot, organization, and overall clarity working?
Structural Edit

Do I know what I want to say, but not how best to say it?
Content Edit

Am I seeing repetition, awkward phrasing, or uneven tone?
Content Edit

Have I already made major revisions and don’t plan to move scenes or sections?
Content Edit or Proofreading

Would I be frustrated if an editor suggested cutting or moving large sections?
Proofreading

Am I confident that it’s nearly ready for submission or publication?
Proofreading

Packaged Services: Multiple Editing Stages in One

Some documents or manuscripts need the whole kit and kaboodle, and that’s okay. In fact, we offer that. Our Total Edit package includes beta reading, structural and content editing, and proofreading. That means our editors would have read your draft several times to complete each tier effectively, which results in a deep and comprehensive understanding of your book.

And bundled services are discounted by a steep margin compared to purchasing each service separately. The Total Edit is our start-to-finish package and works well for writers who are ready to outsource the entire process seamlessly, and can even be combined with layout and cover design services. That truly is a draft-to-publication service.

What’s Right for You?

We would love to work with you, but our primary goal is to help you get your work out into the world. If, after browsing our services or checking out our Service Request Form, you are concerned about cost or time, reach out. We are always ready to strike a deal or offer free advice. We also have coupons, frequent sales, and payment plans through Klarna, Affirm, and Afterpay.

Or, start with some of the information in this post and tackle those pesky editing tasks yourself. Strengthening your revision skills will come in handy down the road and save you money. But don’t forget, a second set of eyes—especially professional eyes—is hard to beat. So, when you are ready, let us know, and we will get to work.